Ideas & systems

Worked examples and mistakes

A mistake in a game is rarely loud. The Ledger keeps a page of the quiet ones, so that you can read them before you make them.

What it is

This page is a set of worked examples. Each one shows a design that works in Vespera and a near miss that looks right and is not. Most mistakes in a game's rules are quiet. Nothing breaks. A player is shut out, or paid twice, or sees nothing.

Each example has three lines: the right version, the wrong version, and what the player sees.

How it works

  1. Read the right version. It is built in the game, and the page says where.
  2. Read the wrong version. It is usually one setting away from the right one.
  3. Check what the player sees. That is how you will notice the mistake in your own game.

The right versions are built and played in Vespera. A wrong version is not built unless a line says the game answered.

In Vespera

In Vespera: Maren and the Bard: a marker, not the reward Play it

Old Maren's Welcome and the Last Bard's Listen each offer a story once.

Right The action asks that the player does not hold the marker Bard Song Heard, and gives the story and the marker.
Wrong The action asks that the player does not hold a reward they could spend or find elsewhere, such as Vesper Marks.
The player sees Right: after the first tap the popover shows only the description, even on a second tap. Wrong: the button comes back when the reward is spent, and never shows if the reward was found first.

In Vespera: The Mural: a replay is not a second tap Play it

The Bard's Mural gives The Bard's Tale, a Ledger Page and 5 XP once.

Right The player replays the tale from the Journal's Story tab with Play. Nothing is paid again. The Ledger Page stays at 7.
Wrong The player taps Study the mural again to see it.
The player sees Right: the mural pans and a caption reads "When it went cold, each guild took a page and scattered." Wrong: the game still offers Study the mural, then refuses with "Must not have The Bard's Tale".

In Vespera: The Coffer and Rust and Ruin: a share or a flat bonus Play it

The Guild Coffer keeps a quarter of what the Outpost's rewards pay. A turn-in that would pay 12 or 13 Vesper Marks paid 16. Rust and Ruin gives a flat extra Iron Ore, so a strike of 2 gave "+3 Iron Ore". See Process awards.

Right A share on a big reward. A flat extra on a small, steady one.
Wrong A share on a tiny sum, or a flat extra on money.
The player sees The Coffer's own 3 Mark dues gained nothing extra from a quarter. A flat +1 on Marks would double a 1 Mark sale, where the Trader's 25 percent leaves it at 1.

In Vespera: The Ledger Page: a requirement written as a cost Play it

Whole Again, Songs of Before and The Founders' Plans each ask for at least 7 Ledger Pages. All three leave them with the player.

Right The page count is a kept requirement, so all three can ask for it.
Wrong Used up is ticked on the pages.
The player sees The first of them would take the pages. The others would shut until the player found them again.

In Vespera: Waystone Memory: captions under the pictures Play it

Each caption waits for Continue.

Right The captions sit on layers 13 and 14, above the maps on 11 and 12. See Text layers.
Wrong The captions sit on layer 10, under the maps.
The player sees Right: each caption shows over its map with Continue. Wrong: the maps hide the words and the button, and the story waits for a tap nobody can make.

In Vespera: The Great Guildhall: Also gives is an extra Play it

Raising the Hall of Wayfinders gives the next tier by itself. Under Also gives it adds one extra, the story Vespera Remembers. See Upgrade.

Right Also gives lists only extras.
Wrong Also gives lists The Great Guildhall, the next tier.
The player sees Right: the Guildhall becomes Level 4 and the story plays by itself. Wrong: the Upgrade already does that, so the reward is a second thing. Not tried in play.

In Vespera: The Coffer's dues: income that does not sleep Play it

Collect dues pays 4 Vesper Marks every 45 seconds, once the player has tapped it.

Right The yield and the wait are sized for hours of absence: the next load pays up to 24 hours of missed rounds at once.
Wrong The author expects it to pay only while the player is at the Outpost.
The player sees Marks went from 101 to 205 when the game was opened after a break: the load paid the missed rounds together. See Idle and clicker recipes.

Good to know

  • Marker, not reward. The gate checks what the player holds now. Pick something only the action gives.
  • Hidden or refused. A story that is gated is hidden. An Open with the same gate is shown, then refused.
  • A quiet mistake shows in play. Play each example once, as a new player, before you trust it.
Under the hood
  • A once-only gate checks what the player holds right now. It does not remember what the player once held.
  • A requirement that is not used up is checked each time, so many actions can share one. A used-up one is taken by the first action that runs.
  • A percent bonus and a flat bonus add up in the order the Buffs and modifiers page gives. Percent bonuses add to each other and do not multiply.
  • A replay from the Journal never reaches the game engine. Its requirements and effects happen once, on the first play.